Renovating historic houses

Does renovating a derelict historic building create a Trigger's broom scenario?

Here’s a question for you:

Should a derelict historic building be renovated and brought back to life, or do we get stuck in the Trigger’s broom scenario where nothing is authentic or original?


There’s no easy answer I’m afraid. Each case needs to be decided on merit. We can’t preserve everything in aspic, but we can’t let things crumble either.


Essentially, every building needs a purpose. That could mean that it’s open to the public to enjoy, helping us to understand the evolution of design, taste, lifestyle and the foibles of human life.


It could mean adding a modern extension or link, juxtaposing two periods in history, something for future generations to engage with.


The National Trust is taking another approach. Clandon Park, near Guildford, was ravaged by fire in April 2015. The damage was so extensive that to rebuild it would mean little of the original 18th century structure would be intact.

However, the fire stripped the building back, exposing a stone and brick skeleton, highlighting how grand houses were designed and created.


Tiny fragments of previous interior styles were discovered including a 18th century wallpaper hidden under a picture rail, and vibrant blue paint on panelling. By analysing these wallpaper and paints, conservationists can develop a fully picture of how the house was decorated, how it was used and the tastes of the people who lived there.


The Clandon Project now seeks to create a living building. Instead of restoring the structure completely, the aim is to provide a backdrop for displays, events and activities.


Currently an empty shell, the National Trust aims to create new walkways and staircases between the different levels, offering unique views of the structure, as well as a roof terrace overlooking the grounds.

For more information, please visit the National Trust website.


If you live in a heritage property and would like advice on how to renovate or restore your property, please drop us a line. We’re passionate about history and would love to chat.


Rear side of house
By Helen McClure • October 2, 2026
Discover Vann, W.D. Caröe’s remarkable Arts & Crafts house near Hambledon, Surrey, where old and new were skilfully woven together to create a historic illusion.
By Helen McClure • September 18, 2026
AI can create beautiful room visuals, but can it replace an interior designer? Discover why human expertise, experience and project management still matter.
By Helen McClure • September 11, 2026
David Cole’s Great Houses of the Arts & Crafts Movement explores 100 remarkable British homes. A personal review of Lutyens, Voysey and the wider movement.
By Helen McClure • September 11, 2026
Discover the architectural layers of Grays Court in York, one of Britain’s oldest continuously occupied houses, from Norman origins to today.
May Morris wallpaper design, birds and flowers
By Helen McClure • August 26, 2026
Discover how William Morris and the Arts & Crafts movement offer a timeless alternative to fast, trend-led interiors.
Drawing of an old house
By Helen McClure • August 24, 2026
Discover the hidden history of Old Birtley, a Grade II listed Surrey house shaped by Tudor builders, working families and a Titanic connection.
Early 20th-century map of Moushill, Surrey
By Helen McClure • August 13, 2026
Discover the fascinating history of the White Lion in Moushill, Surrey, a 16th-century coaching inn linked to a notorious murder that inspired Dickens
By Helen McClure • August 13, 2026
Explore the remarkable history of Moushill Lane, from medieval manor and coaching route to a home for artists, engineers and influential figures.
Moushill Lane
By Helen McClure • August 13, 2026
Discover the history of the Moushill Stores in Milford, from a Portsmouth Road stop off to part of Charles Burgess's pioneering grocery empire
By Helen McClure • July 31, 2026
Explore Littlecroft, Edwin Lutyens' overlooked Arts & Crafts house in Guildford, its maritime influences & why research inspires better restoration